I felt embarrassment for Clint Eastwood more than anything else.
He seemed disoriented, disheveled, a little frail. Dirty Harry as a doddering uncle, muttering inappropriate things at the dinner table while everyone averts their eyes, keeps their head down.
But there’s also this: Did the Republicans really need one more rich white guy rendering a black person invisible? On TV? In prime time?
Perhaps the most important question in all of this is also the most naive one: How does such a spectacle — not just crazy Clint talking to an empty chair but 21st-century presidential politics, generally – do anything to advance civility and honor and human flourishing (let alone informed decision-making) in our public life?
I don’t expect it to be much different when the Democrats gather in Charlotte this week. Same formula: political convention as tightly controlled, carefully composed, neatly packaged product. (That Eastwood’s loopy speech slipped through the cracks of the usual scrutiny and scriptedness must surely have some Romney aides averting their eyes, keeping their heads down).
* * * * *
Aristotle understood politics to be concerned findamentally with the well-being of citizens. The good life, he believed (happiness; eudaimonia in Greek), was the telos — the goal, the end game – of human existence, and participation in the polis was the means for realizing this ultimate purpose. In political community, goods are ordered in ways that all persons may flourish, and no person can flourish apart from a just, well-ordered polis.
Maybe the problem is that in our context we hear that term — “the good life” — and think of Budweiser commercials. Politics and the good life? Politicians are supposed to keep their hands off my good life . . .
* * * * *
Being immersed, as I am these days, in poetry, I find myself reading lots of Mary Oliver. She is sometimes regarded (even dismissed) as a mere (mere!) ”nature” poet, as someone who writes lovely lines about swans and geese but whose poetry lacks the intellectual heft necessary to be considered Important. Timely. Socially Relevant.
But I find Oliver’s meditative poems deeply engaged in the questions of what it means for human beings to flourish and how it is that we should order the goods in our lives for the well-being of all.
We are made for joy, Oliver insists. (Which isn’t too far from Aristotle’s idea that we are made for happiness). Tell me, Oliver asks, what it is you plan to do / with your one wild and precious life?
How is this not, at heart, at the root of all that matters, a political question?
For Oliver, and for Aristotle in a different sort of way, living into the telos of our existence is inseparable from the cultivation of beauty in our lives. The good life is a beautiful life and can never be fully realized apart from a just, well-ordered polis.
But politicians don’t talk this way, of course. And neither do their spokespersons, who do odd, embarrassing things like go on television and ask strange, meaningless questions of an empty chair. And we avert our eyes, keep our heads down. For there is no poetry in politics and we are all the poorer for it.
September 2, 2012 at 7:55 am
One of my friends who is African American made the connection on his FB page between Invisible Obama and Ralph Ellison’s Invisible Man. That said, I was a little surprised and disappointed that Obama made light of it with his little tweet of him in the Presidential chair. He typically has the class and dignity to rise above it all, like the full-grown adult that he is– one under constant attack from little white men.
September 2, 2012 at 8:53 pm
I can’t find any reference to Mary Oliver in that article you’ve linked to, even though two or three of the people commenting say that the original writer talks about her. Has he edited her out of it since it was written, do you think?
September 2, 2012 at 8:55 pm
Ah, just caught up with the reference to her….in the slide show below the main article!
September 4, 2012 at 10:21 pm
Perhaps you failed to watch Mia Love, first generation American, black, and daughter of two parents who immigrated from Haiti. Did you fail to watch Mr. Marco Rubio speak? He is also a first generation American, whose parents immigrated from Cuba. What about Senate candidate Ted Cruz, who is also the son of a Cuban immigrant, and who overcame the party establishment pick from Texas? Did you fail to see him as well?
There was also Artur Davis, who is black, from the south, nominated Barack Obama in 2008, and yet is speaking out against the job he has done since being elected.
Your post intimates that the RNC was just old white rich dudes. That would be a gross mischaracterisation as best.
This week you have the DNC, who has official removed any language of God from their platform. They have codified tax payer funded abortion on demand, and also so called gay marriage.
I am no Republican. I have NEVER voted for a Republican for President, but that will change this November. I don’t even need to mention Mr. Obama’s disdain for our nation and our rule of law the US Constitution, which he has deemed ‘an obstacle.’
September 5, 2012 at 6:31 pm
I feel embarrassed for the United Methodist Church when one of our own ministers – Former governor Ted Strickland – lies and throws political bombs like the best of them (forward to the end of the below video to see his tirade). I also love how he quotes scripture to justify his hate:
It’s also interesting to see how democrats tally votes (they required delegates to show photo ID by the way):
http://bit.ly/PJIs47
Love how the delegates booed god.
Dear Jesus, please finish off the mainline protestant churches. They are in a terminal state of decline and are irrelevant. You deserve better. They were once good but are now pathetic.
September 17, 2012 at 1:18 pm
But the wisdom from above is first pure, then peacable, gentle, reasonable, full of mercy and good fruits, unwavering, without hypocrisy.
And the seed whose fruit is righteousness is sown in peace by those who make peace.
James 3:17-18